What Sub categories should I re-group?

What Sub categories should I re-group?

I dont think much can be regrouped but some

For example Action and thriller/crime?
Adventure and Fantasy?

Any thoughts?

Scifi / Fantasy / Adventure

B-movies - underground / Aliens - unclassable

The line between Action and Thriller/Crime is simple enough I think...So it doesn't have to be merged...

mmm I think action should be regrouped with thriller/crime
Fantasy and adventure I agree
But i'd like to keep the sci-fi part separate cause think it is really one genre on its own
I also dont think B-movie/underground should be regrouped with the aliens/unclassable ones

I have regrouped the adventure part with the Fantasy part
I think the rest looks ok

Yay!

I have also deleted the biography/hostorical evocation part, I think this one is no use. The movies generally have an main genre

that was my idea to delete the biography/historical

i would also delete the war/western, these movies can be classified as action/adventur or drama usually.
i would make the thriller/crime just thriller. crime movie can be classified thriller or action or comedy or whatever depending on the movie.
i would delete the romance, this can be classified under drama, drama/comedy or comedy depending on the movie.
would also delete musical, same reason
would call the horror/gore just horror.
aliens/unclassable just aliens or unclassable (i prefer unclassable)
i would split comedy/drama-comedy in two
i would make action action/adventure and delete the adventure/fantasy (i know you probably wont agree, but if you think of it i think its better)

like this you hve a few less genres what is better in my opinion,
the same kind of movies still go together
every movie goes somewhere
there is less everlap (movies that can be classied in multiple classes)
the names are a bit shorter.

toffetomas wrote:

that was my idea to delete the biography/historical

i would also delete the war/western, these movies can be classified as action/adventur or drama usually.
i would make the thriller/crime just thriller. crime movie can be classified thriller or action or comedy or whatever depending on the movie.
i would delete the romance, this can be classified under drama, drama/comedy or comedy depending on the movie.
would also delete musical, same reason
would call the horror/gore just horror.
aliens/unclassable just aliens or unclassable (i prefer unclassable)
i would split comedy/drama-comedy in two
i would make action action/adventure and delete the adventure/fantasy (i know you probably wont agree, but if you think of it i think its better)

like this you hve a few less genres what is better in my opinion,
the same kind of movies still go together
every movie goes somewhere
there is less everlap (movies that can be classied in multiple classes)
the names are a bit shorter.

but I'd keep the "musical" section

and I'd also keep the "horror/gore" section together, or some films put in there don't belong there anymore (eg. "STACY")

but you are right... "less is more"!!!

well, you dont need the class musical, if you look at the movies there they can all be reclassed as comedy or drama or etc, so thats not a problem.
and the movies in musical are totally different from each other, so.....

for the horror/gore i just ment letting it stay the same but just call it horror (so gore will still be put there)

one other tiny thing instead of writing "B-movies / underground" i would lose the space there and make it B-movies/underground. cause now it looks like the / seperates it, it will make it more clear to read i think.

also maybe the name B-movies/underground can just be called B-movies, cause if you think of it underground movies are b-movies by definition

there is gonna be a Japanese section soon...

but there should also be a Bollywood section too, I think...

but I´m still gonna post the worst of Japan and India in the cult/B-movie corner!!!

Quote :

well, you dont need the class musical, if you look at the movies there they can all be reclassed as comedy or drama or etc, so thats not a problem.
and the movies in musical are totally different from each other, so.....

agreed... but I hate musical, so by keeping that section it's easier for me to know just what to avoid!

mmm, yes I agree with most of this, I also think that having less genre will create less overlap
But I dont agree on deleting the fantasy part. Or maybe I can combined this with Sci-fi?

labrat wrote:

there is gonna be a Japanese section soon...

but there should also be a Bollywood section too, I think...

but I´m still gonna post the worst of Japan and India in the cult/B-movie corner!!!

Quote :

well, you dont need the class musical, if you look at the movies there they can all be reclassed as comedy or drama or etc, so thats not a problem.
and the movies in musical are totally different from each other, so.....

agreed... but I hate musical, so by keeping that section it's easier for me to know just what to avoid!

For Bollywood, I dont mind creating a new part but to be honnest, I only watched one in my life so are you really planning to post some?
Only if there is a big need then I can do so, no problem, but then there should be some posted, else it is not use

For the musical, I thought at first to keep it but then when you think about it, you say you dont like musical, but some are just not traditional musical, for example it is a shame not to see Dancer in the dark.... which is really not a traditional musical. So indeed there are difference between drama and comedie musical...

Chrisy wrote:

For Bollywood, I dont mind creating a new part but to be honnest, I only watched one in my life so are you really planning to post some?
Only if there is a big need then I can do so, no problem, but then there should be some posted, else it is not use

good point... my interrest for Bollywoodflicks has just recently started growing and it will take some time before I have seen enough to start reviewing, so we could always make a Bollywood subforum later, I guess...

BTW... the Asian section looks good!

Well, no problem, I can create a new one if there is really the need. You can just ask when you feel you have some to post

Quote :

Comedy, Drama, Drama Comedy, Action, Thriller, Horror, Sci-fi, Fantasy, Animation, B-Movies, Unclassable

Looks good, if you ask me...

Yes, I had to move some movies around but for some of them I was not totally sure so if you guys could check that the movies you posted are in the correct place, that would be great
If some need to be moved, let me know