watched it tonight and yes, it is very good
It is beautifull from beginning till end, really love that the story he tells is never totally far from their reality with a lot of little details. Trully one of the kind.
But I wont give it more than
for 2 reasons:
1. The main thematic music. This is very personal of course but I rattach this music way too much to the movie
Irréversible, i find it difficult to watch another movie with this music now. It would be a bit the same for me as if they played the
Requiem for a dream music for instance. It would have been nice if they had an original soundtrack...
2. There are a lot of similarities with
Baraka, at least 2 scenes which are exactly the same. And there are maybe more but at least these 2 are totally ripped. I dont know if it is an hommage or not, but it is certainly too much of a coincidence. If you haven't seen
Baraka, watch it, you will see what I mean right away (it is a magnificient piece of work btw) so I dont know what to really think about this choice the director made....
For the rest, I really loved it